Ask Ann: Beer as an anti-inflammatory?
Hello Ann! –
I need an expert opinion on this running/beer question. I’ve heard that beer acts as an anti-inflammatory. Have you ever had a “cold one” after a hard run? Do you think it aids in your recovery? I actually prefer a stronger IPA after a hard run. The stronger IPAs have a higher IBU (International Bitterness Units) rating and I am wondering if this better effects my recovery. Any insight into this or your experience and preferences would be wonderful.
What an excellent question. You must be a very smart dude. Scientific studies have shown that IBUs do indeed help with inflammation. There is a direct correlation between IBUs and the beverage’s rich bouquet of polyphenols, chemical substances found in many plants that, among other things, “suppress viral replication” and “influence the innate immune system positively,” all beneficial for fighting off a cold.
I hate to disappoint but the beer of choice among scientists is indeed non-alcoholic. According to the New York Times in April, 2011, “A new study reports that beer is an excellent recovery beverage for marathon runners. But you may not want to start a raucous celebration just yet. The beer was effective only if it was nonalcoholic.”
Glen, you are probably speculating that alcoholic beer would be drenched in polyphenols, too. Dr. Scheer, of the Technical University of Munich, who did the study, did find that indeed alcoholic beer does contain loads of polyphenols. The key issue is the amount of beer a runner would have to consume. For maximum benefit, the runners in the study had to consume a liter and a half of beer a day.
“We do not know whether the side effects of alcoholic beer would cancel out the positive effects caused by the polyphenols,” Dr. Scheer wrote. “Furthermore, it is not possible to drink one and a half liters of alcoholic beer per day, especially not during strenuous training.” We all know that, right?
There are some wonderful non-alcoholic beers, and, yes indeed, I have been known to grab a cold one after a run. My favorite at the moment is Erdinger Weissbier N/A. A good friend has told me her favorite post-run drink is Kaliber (by Guinness). I have also been known to use beer as an ice pack after a hard race. Don’t knock it: when else can you have two brews with one stone?
Have a question for Ann?